Qurbani Easy

Shariah-Compliant Qurbani • Aqeeqah • Sadqah

Working since 2020 • Has helped 46,000+ people
Islamic Rulings

Your Qurbani in Another City: Whose Eid Time Counts — Yours or the Animal’s Place?

Editorial Team, Qurbani Easy Updated 17/11/2026 6 min read

Last updated: 17 November 2026 | Written for Eid ul Adha 2027
Qurbani Easy Editorial Team • Advised by our panel of Islamic scholars

Quick Answer: When your Qurbani is performed in another city or country by a Wakeel, Hanafi fatwa sources say the timing follows the place where the animal is sacrificed, not where you live. The sacrifice is valid once Eid has arrived and Eid Salah has been held at the animal’s location. Some scholars add a precaution: wait until 10 Dhul Hijjah has begun where you live too, though this is not a condition of validity.

A family in Mumbai books Qurbani to be performed in a village in Uttar Pradesh. Eid is declared a day apart in the two places, or the donor simply hasn’t prayed Eid yet when the animal is sacrificed. Does the Qurbani still count? This happens far more often than people realise, especially with online booking, and the answer turns on one clear principle.

The Rule: The Animal’s Location Governs the Timing

Four separate Hanafi fatwa sources point the same way. Mufti Siraj Desai states that “conditions of Qurbani apply to the country or town where the animal is and not where the owner lives,” and that “the time of Qurbani will be in accordance with the Eid Salaah of the place where the animal is kept” (AskMufti, via islamqa.org). Shaykh Ebrahim Salejee gives the same ruling: “Consideration will be of the place where the Qurbaani is being done,” and “if the day of Qurbaani has already arrived in that place, then the Qurbaani will be valid” (Muftionline, via islamqa.org). Shaykh Yusuf Shabbir notes that “the preferred view appears to be… that the location of the Qurbani is what matters” (IslamicPortal, via islamqa.org).

A Real Case: Donor in the UK, Animal in India

Darul Uloom Deoband was asked about exactly this: a donor in the UK whose Qurbani was being performed in India, where Eid fell on a different day. The answer applied the Indian calendar: “You should offer Qurbani as per Indian calendar on the second or third day of Eid, then it will be valid; otherwise not” (Darul Uloom Deoband, Fatwa 1947/1711, via islamqa.org). The point to take from it is that the valid days were counted by India’s calendar, where the animal was, not the UK’s.

The Cautious View: Wait for Eid Where You Live Too

One scholar adds a precaution worth knowing. Shaykh Yusuf Shabbir writes that “the cautious approach is that one’s Qurbani is only carried out after 10 Dhul Hijjah has begun in his location.” He is clear that this is a precaution, not a validity condition, stating in the same answer that “the Qurbani will be valid even if 10 Dhul Hijjah has not occurred in the UK” when it has occurred where the animal is (IslamicPortal, cited above). So if the animal’s location reaches Eid a day before yours, the Qurbani is still valid there; the cautious option is simply to have it done after your own Eid has started as well.

What This Means Within India

Most Qurbani bookings within India involve the same Eid date across cities, so the issue rarely arises. It matters when moon sighting differs between regions, which does happen in some years, or when the Wakeel’s local Eid Salah finishes before the donor’s. In both cases, the rule above applies: what counts is that Eid has arrived and Eid Salah has been held where the animal is. The donor’s own Eid prayer timing doesn’t hold up the sacrifice elsewhere.

What to Actually Do

First, accept that your Qurbani’s valid window is set by the animal’s location. Second, if you want to follow the cautious view, ask that the sacrifice be scheduled after Eid has begun in your own city too. Third, remember the window still closes at sunset on 12 Dhul Hijjah by the animal’s local calendar, so a late booking is judged by that calendar, not yours. Fourth, if your situation involves something unusual, such as an Eid declared two days apart, confirm with a local qualified scholar.

How Qurbani Easy Helps

Qurbani Easy confirms the date of your Qurbani once the moon is sighted, and the sacrifice is performed by a Wakeel within the valid days at the place where the animal is. See How to Do Qurbani for the full process, or the Qurbani page for current options. For the valid days themselves, see Days and Time of Qurbani.

Frequently Asked Questions

Whose Eid date counts if my Qurbani is done in another city?

The Eid date of the place where the animal is sacrificed counts, according to the Hanafi fatwa sources checked for this guide, not the date in the city where you live.

Can my Qurbani be done before I have prayed Eid myself?

Yes, if Eid Salah has already been held where the animal is. The time of Qurbani follows the Eid Salah of the place where the animal is kept, not your own Eid prayer.

What if Eid is a day earlier where the animal is than where I live?

The Qurbani is valid once Eid has arrived at the animal’s location. One scholar recommends, as a precaution, waiting until Eid has begun in your own city too, but states this is not a condition for validity.

Do the last valid days also follow the animal’s location?

Yes. In the Darul Uloom Deoband case of a UK donor with Qurbani in India, the valid days were counted by the Indian calendar, where the animal was sacrificed.

Does this apply to Qurbani booked within India, not just abroad?

Yes, the same principle applies between cities. It only becomes relevant in years when moon sighting differs between regions or the Eid Salah times differ.

Is appointing a Wakeel in another city valid at all?

Yes, the Hanafi sources cited here all treat performing Qurbani through a Wakeel in another place as valid; their discussion is only about which location’s timing applies.

Citation Sources

• AskMufti, Mufti Siraj Desai, “Qurbani in Different Country” (Hanafi) — islamqa.org — supports that the animal’s location and its Eid Salah govern timing.
• Muftionline, Shaykh Ebrahim Salejee, “Which Place Is Considered for Qurbaani?” (Hanafi) — islamqa.org — supports that the place of sacrifice is considered.
• Darul Uloom Deoband, Fatwa 1947/1711 (Hanafi) — islamqa.org — UK donor, India sacrifice, Indian calendar applied.
• IslamicPortal, Shaykh Yusuf Shabbir, “Qurbani Location Fatwa” (Hanafi) — islamqa.org — supports the preferred view and the cautious, non-binding precaution.

QE
Editorial Team, Qurbani Easy
Trusted since 2020 · India
Chat with us